The Lexicographer's Dilemma The Evolution of 'Proper' English, from Shakespeare to South Park


( ! ) Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/_folio/bookdetails/macmillan/trade-books-for-courses.phtml on line 172
Call Stack
#TimeMemoryFunctionLocation
10.0005235472{main}( )../index.php:0
20.01441235864Bootstrap->start( )../index.php:14
30.07715520728Zend_Controller_Front->dispatch( )../bootstrap.php:86
40.08135857096Zend_Controller_Dispatcher_Standard->dispatch( )../Front.php:954
50.152910125272Zend_Controller_Action->dispatch( )../Standard.php:295
60.152910132456PageBaseController->viewAction( )../Action.php:513
70.159110257888Zend_Controller_Action->render( )../PageBaseController.php:305
80.159110258312Zend_Controller_Action_Helper_ViewRenderer->render( )../Action.php:212
90.159410259272Zend_Controller_Action_Helper_ViewRenderer->renderScript( )../ViewRenderer.php:918
100.159410259512Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../ViewRenderer.php:897
110.159510276560Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
120.159910296040include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/page/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
130.166110356632Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:10
140.166110357072Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:10
150.166110357512call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
160.166110357936Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
170.166210361720Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
180.166210378456Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
190.166610395152include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/page/core/default_1_canvas.phtml' )../View.php:108
200.166610398168Zend_View->partial( )../default_1_canvas.phtml:6
210.166610398608Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../default_1_canvas.phtml:6
220.166610399048call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
230.166610399472Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
240.166710404456Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
250.166810421176Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
260.166810421464include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/canvas/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
270.166810422912Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:7
280.166810423352Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:7
290.166810423792call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
300.166810424216Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
310.166910428224Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
320.166910444944Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
330.166910445232include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/snippet/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
340.167010446864Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:7
350.167010447304Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:7
360.167010447744call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
370.167010448168Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
380.167110452400Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
390.167110469144Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
400.167410472392include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/folio_bookdetails.phtml' )../View.php:108
410.167410473288Zend_View->partial( )../folio_bookdetails.phtml:10
420.167410473728Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../folio_bookdetails.phtml:10
430.167410474168call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
440.167410474592Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
450.167510477912Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
460.167510494688Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
470.168410571808include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/_folio/bookdetails/macmillan/trade-books-for-courses.phtml' )../View.php:108

Walker & Company


( ! ) Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/_folio/bookdetails/macmillan/trade-books-for-courses.phtml on line 188
Call Stack
#TimeMemoryFunctionLocation
10.0005235472{main}( )../index.php:0
20.01441235864Bootstrap->start( )../index.php:14
30.07715520728Zend_Controller_Front->dispatch( )../bootstrap.php:86
40.08135857096Zend_Controller_Dispatcher_Standard->dispatch( )../Front.php:954
50.152910125272Zend_Controller_Action->dispatch( )../Standard.php:295
60.152910132456PageBaseController->viewAction( )../Action.php:513
70.159110257888Zend_Controller_Action->render( )../PageBaseController.php:305
80.159110258312Zend_Controller_Action_Helper_ViewRenderer->render( )../Action.php:212
90.159410259272Zend_Controller_Action_Helper_ViewRenderer->renderScript( )../ViewRenderer.php:918
100.159410259512Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../ViewRenderer.php:897
110.159510276560Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
120.159910296040include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/page/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
130.166110356632Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:10
140.166110357072Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:10
150.166110357512call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
160.166110357936Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
170.166210361720Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
180.166210378456Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
190.166610395152include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/page/core/default_1_canvas.phtml' )../View.php:108
200.166610398168Zend_View->partial( )../default_1_canvas.phtml:6
210.166610398608Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../default_1_canvas.phtml:6
220.166610399048call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
230.166610399472Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
240.166710404456Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
250.166810421176Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
260.166810421464include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/canvas/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
270.166810422912Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:7
280.166810423352Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:7
290.166810423792call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
300.166810424216Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
310.166910428224Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
320.166910444944Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
330.166910445232include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/snippet/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
340.167010446864Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:7
350.167010447304Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:7
360.167010447744call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
370.167010448168Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
380.167110452400Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
390.167110469144Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
400.167410472392include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/folio_bookdetails.phtml' )../View.php:108
410.167410473288Zend_View->partial( )../folio_bookdetails.phtml:10
420.167410473728Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../folio_bookdetails.phtml:10
430.167410474168call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
440.167410474592Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
450.167510477912Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
460.167510494688Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
470.168410571808include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/_folio/bookdetails/macmillan/trade-books-for-courses.phtml' )../View.php:108

0802777694

9780802777690

336 Pages

$17.00

Request Desk Copy Request Exam Copy

In its long history, the English language has had many lawmakers—those who have tried to regulate or otherwise organize the way we speak. The Lexicographer's Dilemma poses a pair of questions—what does proper English mean, and who gets to say what's right? Our ideas of correct or proper English have a history, and today's debates over the state of the language—whether about Ebonics in schools, the unique use of language in a South Park episode, or split infinitives in the Times—make sense only in historical context. As historian Jack Lynch has discovered, every rule has a human history, and the characters who populate his narrative are as interesting for their obsessions as for their erudition. Charting the evolution of English with wit and intelligence, he provides a rich historical perspective that makes us appreciate a new the hard-won standards we now enjoy.

REVIEWS

Praise for The Lexicographer's Dilemma

"This delightful look at efforts through the centuries to define and control the English language turns out to be a history of human exasperation, frustration and free-floating angst. People tend to go nuts around the English language. Of course, most of us are nuts anyway, but the language is always there, in the ether, or staring at us from a page, and if we're feeling particularly cranky, it never fails to provide a ready excuse for us to fly off the handle."—Carolyn See, The Washington Post

“Lynch recognizes that grace, clarity, and precision of expression are paramount. His many well-chosen and entertaining examples support his conclusion that prescriptions and pedantry will always give way to change, and that we should stop fretting, relax, and embrace it.”—The Boston Globe

“In his sprightly new history of the notion of ‘proper’ English . . . Lynch [asks] us all to calm down, please, and recognize that ‘proper’ English is a recent and changeable institution.”—Salon

“Lynch’s highly readable book will appeal to all users of the English language, from word buffs to scholars alike.”—Library Journal

Reviews from Goodreads

BACK

BOOK EXCERPTS

Read an Excerpt

Jack Lynch is a professor of English at Rutgers University and a Johnson scholar, having studied the great lexicographer for nearly a decade. In addition to his books on Johnson and on Elizabethan England, he has written journal articles and scholarly reviews, and hosts a Web site devoted to these topics at http://andromeda. rutgers.edu/~jlynch/18th/. He is the author of Becoming Shakespeare and Samuel Johnson's Insults and the editor of Samuel Johnson's Dictionary. He lives in Lawrenceville, NJ.

( ! ) Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/_folio/bookdetails/macmillan/includes-trade-books/book-excerpts-section.phtml on line 24
Call Stack
#TimeMemoryFunctionLocation
10.0005235472{main}( )../index.php:0
20.01441235864Bootstrap->start( )../index.php:14
30.07715520728Zend_Controller_Front->dispatch( )../bootstrap.php:86
40.08135857096Zend_Controller_Dispatcher_Standard->dispatch( )../Front.php:954
50.152910125272Zend_Controller_Action->dispatch( )../Standard.php:295
60.152910132456PageBaseController->viewAction( )../Action.php:513
70.159110257888Zend_Controller_Action->render( )../PageBaseController.php:305
80.159110258312Zend_Controller_Action_Helper_ViewRenderer->render( )../Action.php:212
90.159410259272Zend_Controller_Action_Helper_ViewRenderer->renderScript( )../ViewRenderer.php:918
100.159410259512Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../ViewRenderer.php:897
110.159510276560Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
120.159910296040include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/page/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
130.166110356632Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:10
140.166110357072Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:10
150.166110357512call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
160.166110357936Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
170.166210361720Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
180.166210378456Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
190.166610395152include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/page/core/default_1_canvas.phtml' )../View.php:108
200.166610398168Zend_View->partial( )../default_1_canvas.phtml:6
210.166610398608Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../default_1_canvas.phtml:6
220.166610399048call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
230.166610399472Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
240.166710404456Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
250.166810421176Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
260.166810421464include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/canvas/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
270.166810422912Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:7
280.166810423352Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:7
290.166810423792call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
300.166810424216Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
310.166910428224Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
320.166910444944Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
330.166910445232include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/snippet/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
340.167010446864Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:7
350.167010447304Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:7
360.167010447744call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
370.167010448168Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
380.167110452400Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
390.167110469144Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
400.167410472392include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/folio_bookdetails.phtml' )../View.php:108
410.167410473288Zend_View->partial( )../folio_bookdetails.phtml:10
420.167410473728Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../folio_bookdetails.phtml:10
430.167410474168call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
440.167410474592Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
450.167510477912Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
460.167510494688Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
470.168410571808include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/_folio/bookdetails/macmillan/trade-books-for-courses.phtml' )../View.php:108
480.460410773096include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/_folio/bookdetails/macmillan/includes-trade-books/book-excerpts-section.phtml' )../trade-books-for-courses.phtml:320
BACK

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


    ( ! ) Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/_folio/bookdetails/macmillan/includes-trade-books/about-the-author-section.phtml on line 24
    Call Stack
    #TimeMemoryFunctionLocation
    10.0005235472{main}( )../index.php:0
    20.01441235864Bootstrap->start( )../index.php:14
    30.07715520728Zend_Controller_Front->dispatch( )../bootstrap.php:86
    40.08135857096Zend_Controller_Dispatcher_Standard->dispatch( )../Front.php:954
    50.152910125272Zend_Controller_Action->dispatch( )../Standard.php:295
    60.152910132456PageBaseController->viewAction( )../Action.php:513
    70.159110257888Zend_Controller_Action->render( )../PageBaseController.php:305
    80.159110258312Zend_Controller_Action_Helper_ViewRenderer->render( )../Action.php:212
    90.159410259272Zend_Controller_Action_Helper_ViewRenderer->renderScript( )../ViewRenderer.php:918
    100.159410259512Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../ViewRenderer.php:897
    110.159510276560Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
    120.159910296040include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/page/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
    130.166110356632Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:10
    140.166110357072Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:10
    150.166110357512call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
    160.166110357936Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
    170.166210361720Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
    180.166210378456Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
    190.166610395152include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/page/core/default_1_canvas.phtml' )../View.php:108
    200.166610398168Zend_View->partial( )../default_1_canvas.phtml:6
    210.166610398608Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../default_1_canvas.phtml:6
    220.166610399048call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
    230.166610399472Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
    240.166710404456Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
    250.166810421176Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
    260.166810421464include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/canvas/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
    270.166810422912Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:7
    280.166810423352Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:7
    290.166810423792call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
    300.166810424216Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
    310.166910428224Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
    320.166910444944Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
    330.166910445232include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/snippet/view.phtml' )../View.php:108
    340.167010446864Zend_View->partial( )../view.phtml:7
    350.167010447304Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../view.phtml:7
    360.167010447744call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
    370.167010448168Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
    380.167110452400Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
    390.167110469144Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
    400.167410472392include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/folio_bookdetails.phtml' )../View.php:108
    410.167410473288Zend_View->partial( )../folio_bookdetails.phtml:10
    420.167410473728Zend_View_Abstract->__call( )../folio_bookdetails.phtml:10
    430.167410474168call_user_func_array ( )../Abstract.php:342
    440.167410474592Zend_View_Helper_Partial->partial( )../Abstract.php:342
    450.167510477912Zend_View_Abstract->render( )../Partial.php:105
    460.167510494688Zend_View->_run( )../Abstract.php:880
    470.168410571808include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/_folio/bookdetails/macmillan/trade-books-for-courses.phtml' )../View.php:108
    480.461610815768include( '/mnt/nfs/nfs01/www/sites/sharedcode/supadu_core_live/application/views/scripts/apps/renderings/_folio/bookdetails/macmillan/includes-trade-books/about-the-author-section.phtml' )../trade-books-for-courses.phtml:332
  • Jack Lynch is a professor of English at Rutgers University and a Johnson scholar, having studied the great lexicographer for nearly a decade. In addition to his books on Johnson and on Elizabethan England, he has written journal articles and scholarly reviews, and hosts a website devoted to these topics at http://andromeda. rutgers.edu/~jlynch/18th/. He is the author of Becoming Shakespeare and Samuel Johnson's Insults and the editor of Samuel Johnson's Dictionary. He lives in Lawrenceville, NJ.
BACK