For ten years Angelina Amaro has kept a secret. She is in love with Sal Martucci, the man who betrayed her father, Mafia godfather Paul Amaro, and sent him away to prison. Ever since ratting out the Godfather, Sal has been on the run. Abandoning the humdrum life of the Witness Protection Program, now he is in Key West, tending bar and running some rackets on the side with the local mobsters. When Angelina spots Sal's hands in the background of a home video, she heads straight for Mile Marker One to find him. Before long, her daddy is on to Angelina's whereabouts, and Sal's sleazy cronies are wising up to the significance of having a mafia princess in their midst. As Key West transforms into fair Verona, a touching and hilarious tale of love, the mob, revenge, redemption, and even some cross-dressing unfolds.