Into the Rose Garden
This is the story of a ghost who walked into my life on a sunlit Sunday morning in early summer, and would not let go of me, however much I might wish, at times, to be free of her. Her name is Catherine Dior, and she arrived as I wandered through the garden of La Colle Noire, her brother Christian’s graceful château in the hills of rural Provence; a place she often visited, and a house where she lived for a while, after his sudden death of a heart attack at the age of fifty-two, in 1957.
Catherine was twelve years younger than Christian – he was born in 1905, the second son of a prosperous family; she was the youngest of five children, born in 1917, just before their eldest brother, Raymond, began his service in the French army during the First World War. But thoughts of war were far from my mind during that enchanting day at La Colle Noire. Instead, I was seduced by the exquisite beauty of the house, bought and restored by Christian Dior with the proceeds of the successful brand that he had created in 1946.
His debut collection, shown in Paris on 12 February 1947, had been christened the New Look by Carmel Snow, the editor of Harper’s Bazaar (a position that I, too, have been privileged to hold). But despite the name, it was as much a nostalgic reimagining of the Belle Epoque, the golden years before the Great War. This was the era of Christian’s early childhood, growing up in the secure surroundings of the Dior family home in Granville, on the coast of Normandy. His mother, Madeleine, had dressed in the romantic, sweeping gowns of the period, and it was these that inspired Dior’s creation of swishing full skirts and a rounded hourglass silhouette, achieved with a corseted waist and padded bust. Yet equally important to Dior’s conception of ‘flower-like women’ that emerged in his couture salon in Paris was his mother’s love of gardening. Madeleine’s passion – which she passed on to Christian and Catherine – had found expression in the expansive garden she established at Granville, a miracle of hope and desire, built on a rocky outcrop overlooking the churning sea, several hundred feet below.
Her husband, Maurice Dior, had inherited the family fertiliser business, and on days when the wind was blowing in the wrong direction, the stench of his factories would drift across the town, although seldom as far as Les Rhumbs. But for all its unsavoury connotations, the guano industry paid for Madeleine’s magical creation on a barren cliff top: tender flowerbeds protected from the salt-laden storms by hardy conifer trees, and most importantly of all, the roses that were (and remain) the centrepiece of the garden.
Roses continue to bloom everywhere at La Colle Noire, too: tumbling over pergolas and climbing up the outside walls, their tendrils gently tapping at the windows; luxuriant even on the patterned floral wallpaper and chintz furnishings within. And beyond the terraces and herbaceous borders is a meadow of a thousand rose bushes, whose flowers are still gathered (just as they have been since the field was planted to Christian Dior’s original specifications) to produce an essential ingredient for his perfumes. The first of these, and closest to Christian’s heart, was launched alongside the New Look collection, and named in honour of his beloved sister Catherine: Miss Dior.
Catherine outlived her brother by five decades, and died in June 2008, not far from La Colle Noire, at her home in the neighbouring village of Callian. Here she too cultivated roses, both for her own pleasure and to be distilled as an essence for Dior’s perfume manufacturers in nearby Grasse. She had been a loyal and loving sister throughout her brother’s life, and continued to be so after his death, honouring his legacy in many ways, including her consistent support for the Christian Dior museum that was eventually established in Granville.
But while Christian became one of the most famous Frenchmen in the world – a celebrated name alongside Charles de Gaulle – the remarkable story of Catherine Dior has never been fully explored. The little I knew of her life I had gathered from the Dior archives before I first visited La Colle Noire: she had lived with Christian in Paris in the late 1930s, and shared a small farm with him during the war, on the outskirts of Callian, where they grew vegetables, as well as roses and jasmine. Then she joined the French Resistance, and was captured by the Gestapo, before being deported to Ravensbrück, a German concentration camp for women.
One of the Dior archivists, Vincent Leret, had come to meet me at La Colle Noire on this particular Sunday morning, to discuss the possibility of me writing a new biography of Christian Dior. Yet as we spoke, I found myself asking him more and more questions about the mysterious Catherine, who appeared to have rarely referred to her involvement in the Resistance, nor her time in Germany. Vincent had known Catherine – before moving to his job at the Dior archives in Paris, he worked for the museum in Granville – and they corresponded, whenever he had queries that she could answer about her brother. But she gave nothing away of her wartime experiences, and he said that he felt it would have been impolite to press her for more information. As for the other writers who had previously chronicled the life of Christian Dior, few were particularly interested in Catherine, or even aware of her deportation to Ravensbrück. It was as if the hermetic world of haute couture had no concern for a woman such as Catherine Dior, or for the suffering that she had endured; nor even as to whether her experiences had played a part in her brother’s legendary vision of fashion and femininity.
I wrote some notes, and then walked down to the meadow of roses, where butterflies danced about the petals, accompanied by a chorus of birdsong and bees. All was peaceful, caressed by gentle sunlight; yet as I stood there, I wished with all my heart that I had met Catherine before her death, a decade previously. And it was then, in that instant, that the seed was sown within me; a desire more akin to obsession – even possession – that I would tell the story of this silent woman and her unknown comrades, who had somehow survived Ravensbrück and returned to France; but to a France where many of their compatriots preferred simply to forget the war years and disregard the shame of collaboration.
I did not hear Catherine’s voice; the blue skies did not open. But the scent of the roses seemed to contain within it a question: was it conceivable that so much beauty had arisen from the ashes of the Second World War? And if so, what message might Catherine Dior have for us today, even if she never said another word.
Catherine Dior aged thirty, in 1947.
The Dior family in their garden, c.1920.Catherine sits in the middle, between her parents. Behind them, left to right, Christian, Jacqueline, Bernard and Raymond.
The Garden Maze
A soft rain is falling over the midsummer roses that are blooming in the garden of Les Rhumbs, and a sea mist is gathering, veiling the solid lines of the house. This substantial late-nineteenth-century villa, positioned high above the Normandy town of Granville, overlooking the English Channel, was the childhood home of Christian Dior. Hence the decision to turn it into a museum that cherishes his heritage, while the surrounding garden, created by his mother, has become a park open to the public. It is surprisingly quiet this morning in the grounds, perhaps because of the damp weather, although the museum has several dozen visitors who have come to see a new exhibition, dedicated to Princess Grace of Monaco, and displaying clothes designed for her by Christian Dior.
I’ve just been given a guided tour of the exhibition, each section staged in a different room that had been lived in by the Dior family in the early decades of the twentieth century, and I can’t help feeling a strange blurring of time. For while I am admiring Princess Grace’s outfits from the 1950s, and watching her glide on continuous loops of film, wearing the same couture gowns that are now preserved, inanimate, in glass vitrines, I am also searching for any clues about Catherine Dior that might be hidden in the fabric of the building. The dead princess walks through her palace in Monaco on the video screens, beckoning towards her lost life, as if in an uncanny fairytale. But I do not want to be distracted by this ghostly presence, nor by her silken sartorial relics.
Instead, I’m hoping to discover an earlier era, when Catherine was a child. She seems absent, however, even in the small bedroom that had been hers, where a short text explains her role in the story of Christian Dior: Catherine was Christian’s favourite sister, and when he introduced his first perfume in 1947, he christened it Miss Dior for her, and described it as ‘the fragrance of love’. So it seems appropriate that I should be wearing the same scent on my trip to Granville. The original formula is classed, in the specialist terminology of perfumery, as a ‘green chypre’, blending complex notes of galbanum (a distinctive-smelling plant resin), bergamot, patchouli and oakmoss, with the warmth of jasmine and rose at its floral heart. And just for a moment, standing in Catherine’s former bedroom, I become aware of this unmistakable scent; not on my own skin, but emanating from some other, unseen source … perhaps the huge flagon of perfume presented to Princess Grace by Christian Dior, on show in a nearby gallery?
None of the rooms in Les Rhumbs is furnished. Instead, they are lined with museum cabinets for the display of artefacts, drawings and photographs; on this occasion, relating mostly to Princess Grace’s wardrobe. Yet for all the poignancy of these objects – in particular, the image of a youthful Grace Kelly, wearing an ethereal white Dior gown at the ball celebrating her engagement to Prince Rainier in 1956, unaware that she would die before growing old – Les Rhumbs remains a monument to a more distant past. For this is the place where Maurice and Madeleine Dior moved at the beginning of the century and raised their five children. They had married in 1898, when Madeleine was a beautiful nineteen-year-old girl; Maurice Dior, at twenty-six, was already an ambitious young man, intent on expanding the fertiliser manufacturing business that his grandfather had set up in 1832. By 1905, Maurice and his cousin Lucien were running the flourishing company together, and its growing success was reflected in their social ascendancy. Lucien Dior would become a politician, and remained in parliament until his death in 1932, while a rivalry developed between his wife Charlotte and Madeleine, apparently arising from their competitive aspirations to be the most fashionably dressed chatelaines of the wealthiest households.
I have brought my battered paperback copy of Christian Dior’s memoir, with his evocative memories of Les Rhumbs, and the exterior remains just as he described it: ‘roughcast in a very soft pink, mixed with grey gravelling … these two shades have remained my favourite colours in couture.’ But the elaborately decorated interiors that he described in such detail have vanished: gone are the china shepherdesses, glass bon-bon dishes, and all the other ornaments that Christian remembered in such detail. I have read and reread his autobiography many times but for some reason, it is only today that I realise he does not mention his brothers or sisters by name. Indeed, he only refers to one brother – and then only briefly – and to his beloved Catherine. It is as if Raymond and Jacqueline never existed. Yet here in the entrance hall of the museum, the siblings remain gathered together in a family photograph: Raymond, the eldest, born on 27 October 1899; then Christian, who was born on 21 January 1905 (the same year that his father bought Les Rhumbs); followed by Jacqueline on 20 June 1908, Bernard on 27 October 1910, and seven years later, the baby of the family, Catherine, on 2 August 1917.
Les Rhumbs has a spectacular setting, standing proud on a granite headland, with a magnificent view across the bay. It had been built by a ship-owner, and its name comes from a nautical term referring to the points on the face of a compass, traditionally known as the ‘rose of the winds’, which is itself a symbol that appears on an original mosaic floor inside the villa. Today, the sky is a gentle grey – Dior grey – and the sea merges into the horizon. After my tour of the exhibition, I have been granted permission to spend the remainder of the day writing in what was the Dior children’s playroom in the garden. It is set some distance away from the house, hidden at the end of a path, out of sight of onlookers – yet once inside, the view from the windows is unexpectedly dramatic. Two sides of the room are glazed, and it seems to be constructed on a sheer drop, with a vista of the jagged rocks below. The tide is out, and the sand bars exposed, the beach deserted, as gulls fly overhead, their melancholy cries calling across the waves.
The Dior family home, Les Rhumbs, in Granville, on the Normandy coast.
How might such an outlook have shaped the hopes and dreams of the Dior children? Clearly, it was very much on the mind of Christian Dior, when he wrote his memoir in 1956, the year before his sudden death. ‘Our house at Granville,’ he observed, ‘like all Anglo-Norman buildings at the end of the last century, was perfectly hideous. All the same I look back on it with tenderness as well as amazement. In a certain sense, my whole way of life was influenced by its architecture and environment.’
Christian’s earliest memories were rooted at Les Rhumbs, which remained the family’s primary residence, although they also spent some time in Paris. In 1911 Maurice Dior bought an apartment in the opulent 16th arrondissement of the city; but during the First World War, they lived entirely at Granville, thereafter returning to Paris in 1919, to a larger apartment on Rue Louis-David, in the same district, when Christian was a teenage schoolboy at the nearby Lycée Gerson. Catherine, meanwhile, was educated at home by a governess, and at a girls’ school in Granville; the Dior archives contain several evocative photographs of her playing on the beach as a child. Certainly, she felt sufficiently strongly about Les Rhumbs to have supported the initiative that it should become a museum, attending its opening ceremony in 1997, and serving as its honorary president from 1999 until her death. It was thanks to her recollections of the past that the garden was restored as closely as possible to its original design, and the wrought-iron conservatory at the front of the villa filled with a selection of palms and ferns, just as it had been under her mother’s stewardship. Catherine continued to correspond with the museum curators, providing concise answers to their questions about the planting of the garden; she remembered it as ‘a verdant fortress’ protected from the wind by ramparts of trees, and shored up with great mounds of earth that had been transplanted to the headland upon which the house was built. Her brother Christian, she recalled, had trained roses, honeysuckle and wisteria to climb a white wooden pergola; and together they would watch the goldfish that swam beneath the water lilies in the pond. As for their mother, Catherine described her as ‘a remarkable botanist’, with a profound understanding of the Granville climate and soil. And despite Madeleine Dior’s strictness with the children, Catherine made a brief yet intriguing reference to her mother ‘closing her eyes’ and giving them the freedom to create two flowerbeds, one in the shape of a tiger, and the other a butterfly.
Christian’s surviving writing also provides a sense of the emotional resonance and powerful influence of the landscape. The young trees that were planted, as he described them in his memoir, ‘grew up, as I did, against the wind and the tides. This is no figure of speech, since the garden hung right over the sea, which could be seen through the railings, and lay exposed to all the turbulence of the weather, as if in prophecy of the troubles of my own life … the walls which encompassed the garden were not enough, any more than the precautions encompassing my childhood were enough, to shield us from storms.’
For this is a home built on the very edge of France, where the land gives way to the sea. The original iron railings and stone walls still enclose the garden – although they are not sufficiently high to conceal the cemetery adjoining the property. And for all the bourgeois respectability of the house, and the care that has gone into planning and maintaining the garden, the sea and the sky are so vast that any human endeavour to create stability might seem reckless. Yet the Diors had lived and prospered in Granville for many generations; their wealth based on the enterprise of Christian’s great-grandfather, who imported guano from South America into Normandy, to supply raw materials for the fertiliser industry. ‘L’engrais Dior, c’est d’or!’ proclaimed the company’s publicity (‘Dior fertiliser is gold!’). But Christian declared himself horrified on his few visits to the family’s foul-smelling factories – ‘they have left appalling memories,’ he declared in his memoir, establishing in him a ‘horror of machines’ and a ‘firm resolve’ never to work in such an unpleasant environment.
Instead, like his sister Catherine, he preferred to stay at home and help their mother in the garden, away from the malodorous Dior factories. Christian went so far as to learn by heart the names and descriptions of flowers in the illustrated seed catalogues that were delivered to Les Rhumbs, while Madeleine Dior’s love of roses was inherited by her youngest child, Catherine, who made it her life’s work to grow and nurture them. If the Dior children regarded their parents as distant figures of authority – as is suggested by Christian’s biographer, Marie-France Pochna, who noted that they were raised in an era ‘when open demonstrations of affection were considered likely to weaken the character and strictness was the norm’ – it might also be possible that the way to their mother’s heart was through her cherished garden.
Aside from the garden, the place that Christian felt safest in was the linen-room, where ‘the housemaids and seamstresses … told me fairy stories of devils … Dusk drew on, night fell and there I lingered … absorbed in watching the women round the oil-lamp plying their needles … From that time I have kept a nostalgia for stormy nights, fog-horns, the tolling of the cemetery-bell, and even the Norman drizzle in which my childhood passed.’
These, then, were the shadows of devils and the dead that were kept at bay during the gilded age of the Belle Epoque, when Les Rhumbs had not yet been touched by the threat of war or financial ruin. But what of Catherine, born when the battles of the First World War were raging? Her birth certificate gives her name as Ginette Marie Catherine Dior; family lore has it that it was her brother Bernard who first chose to call her Catherine, rather than Ginette, when she was still a baby. Pictures of her at Les Rhumbs show a solemn little girl, dressed in starched white cotton and lace; her parents are stern, somewhat remote, Christian a more gentle-looking figure standing behind them.
I close my eyes, searching for Catherine, trying to envisage her as a small child in the garden, just outside, playing hide and seek. Catch me if you can, whispers the imaginary child, and then her voice is gone, and I can hear only the sound of the wind murmuring in the chimney, sighing in the empty fireplace beside me.
The Dior family album. This page, clockwise from top left: Catherine on the beach at Granville; Catherine and friends; Catherine; Catherine and Bernard; Catherine, 1920; the Dior children.
Clockwise from top left: Raymond; Christian, Bernard and Jacqueline with their governess Marthe Lefebvre, 1916; Jacqueline, Christian and Raymond; Madeleine Dior; Catherine; Christian.
Clockwise from top left: the clifftop garden of Les Rhumbs; Madeleine and Maurice Dior; Les Rhumbs; Madeleine’s mother, Marie-Juliette Surosne; Christian (left) and Raymond in the garden; Catherine.
The Dior family album. This page, clockwise from top left: Christian at Raymond’s wedding, 1925; Raymond and his bride; Maurice and Madeleine Dior at the wedding; Madeleine Dior; Les Rhumbs.
Through the windows, I notice two tiny figures walking along the beach in the distance, an adult and a child; as the rain becomes heavier, they disappear out of sight. The grey sea mist is thickening; the daylight seems to be dissolving into the fog; the glass of the playroom’s windows is darkening, the wind growing wilder. And I feel a glimmer of understanding as to why Christian and Catherine felt such an attachment to Les Rhumbs, yet chose not to return to live here, even when they had the means to do so in adulthood. For this is a place where journeys begin, a starting point that could never be entirely forgotten; the restless waves and soaring seabirds a constant reminder of what might lie beyond the house on the headland.
There is something about the view of unyielding granite cliffs and rocks that might reflect the severity that Catherine attributed to her mother. As she said in a rare interview with Marie-France Pochna, in 1993, Madeleine Dior was a disciplinarian: ‘My mother was severe with the boys, and even more so with the girls.’ But such maternal sternness is not enough to explain the character of Catherine, or to understand the haunting atmosphere of this garden built on stone. So I decide to brave the rain, and leave the warmth of the playroom for a brief excursion. The brisk sea breeze is cold, buffeting the roses, their bruised, delicate petals falling to the damp earth, like confetti after a wedding.
Just along the path, I find a maze made out of privet hedges, and remember that one of the curators in the Dior archives told me that Catherine, in old age, had described this to him as an important feature of the garden in her childhood. I am tall enough to be able to see over the hedges, but a little girl, running through the green labyrinth, would have to know it very well to find her way out. I know my own way, comes a whisper in my head, though I cannot be sure whether it is mine, or a memory of my lost sister’s voice, when we played together in the secret gardens of our own childhood.
If the ghost of Catherine is indeed here, she is not inclined to speak to me, in this, her private domain. The playroom is usually closed to visitors; it has been unlocked for me today as a special dispensation. And why should an adult sit alone in a playroom? I cannot envisage Madeleine Dior approving of this, nor encouraging much in the way of playfulness. As Christian himself wrote in his memoir: ‘My early years were those of a very good, very well-brought-up little boy, watched over by vigilant fräuleins, and seemingly quite incapable of mingling in the hurly-burly of life.’
As I reread his words in my well-thumbed copy of his memoir, I am struck, for the first time, by the reference to German governesses, and wonder what became of them during the First World War. The answer comes a few pages later: ‘The outbreak of war caught us by surprise at Granville … At first our fräulein refused to go, since she thought, as everyone did, that the cataclysm was impossible. She lived completely as one of the family, but when war broke out, she declared to our terrified amazement that she was ready, if needs be, to go “bang-bang” at the French soldiers…’ As a consequence, a twenty-five-year-old French governess, Marthe Lefebvre (soon known affectionately as ‘Ma’), was employed by the Diors in 1915, and she was to remain with them for the rest of her life.
Long after Christian discovered the delights of the capital city, he remained devoted to the family home in Granville, and to the grounds in which he had spent so much time as a small boy. In 1925 – when he was supposed to be hard at work in Paris as a student of political science, having been refused permission by his parents to study architecture – Christian found the time to design a new garden feature at Les Rhumbs, with arched trellises covered by roses surrounding a pool of water, complete with a small fountain.
Copyright © 2021 by Justine Picardie