Ghost in the Memorabilia
July 12, 2019.
There are three steamer trunks in the spare bedroom of Maynard Smith Jr.’s home in Seminole, Florida. Inside the boxes are the artifacts from the lifetime of his father, a World War II veteran, B-17 gunner, and the first enlisted Army airman ever to receive the Congressional Medal of Honor.
Maynard Harrison Smith Sr. lived with his son and daughter-in-law in Florida during his final years, and these trunks contain the keepsakes that he left behind when he died in 1984. No one’s opened them in decades.
At age seventy-two, Smith Jr. remains a large man. These days he is attached to an oxygen line, and trails a slender, green umbilical hose when he moves around the house. He’s a Vietnam veteran; his father used his connections in Washington, D.C., to bump his son to the front of the two-year Coast Guard recruitment list, saving him from being drafted into the Army. Smith Jr. ended up in combat anyway, serving as a 5-inch gunner on the 254-foot cutter Winona.
Coast Guard cutters provided fire support for men on shore and escorted swift boats; Smith Jr. volunteered to ride on those small craft on several missions, one of which ended with a dash back to the ship with his finger plugging a gunny sergeant’s bullet hole. The younger Smith also ran the nightly, onboard poker game and as such was flush with money. He’s proud of his service, but certainly didn’t want to go: “I said to myself, I can’t run off to Canada, not with the father I got.”
The father and son lived together, ran a publishing business, and shot pool at halls across the country. Over their lifetimes they backed each other up in bar fights and attended presidential inaugurations. And they hunted and fished.
“I was talking with my dad one time in a field, and this pheasant came up flying along the wood line,” Smith Jr. recalls. “He followed it and popped it off. He said that he learned how to follow birds and stuff like that because of his training on the .50 caliber. You know? You have to lead the plane.”
Only a faint echo of the elder Maynard Smith can still be felt in the home, a pleasant, roomy one-story house with a screened-in pool just outside of Tampa. There are photos of Smith Sr. and a few items on display that carry his stamp, like the model of a wooden boat in the living room bearing one of his nicknames, “Snuffy.”
But open a steamer trunk and Smith Sr. himself erupts from within, announcing his arrival with a flurry of yellowed newspaper clippings, faded photos, military documents, Christmas cards, and programs from various military appreciation events and reunions. His son pulls out these memories by the handful.
Here’s a photo of Smith Sr. shaking hands with President John Kennedy, who towers over him. Here’s a news clipping featuring Smith at the elbow of the governor of Michigan in 1945. Here are his honorable discharge papers from the Army Air Forces; he’s a private, having been demoted after receiving the Medal of Honor. Here’s a program from a Medal of Honor Society event in Hawaii in the early 1980s, with a woman’s name and hotel room number scrawled on one page. Here’s a postcard to his mother written from aerial gunnery school in Texas, early in his wartime military career, and underneath it a cryptic photo from an oasis in North Africa, with a handwritten notation saying MY QUARTERS with an arrow pointing to a hilltop building on the horizon.
Maynard Smith Jr. pulls more of his father’s memories from the steamer trunks, spreading the fragments across the surface of the bed. The ghostly form of a man emerges: a proud veteran, an acknowledged hero, a newspaper publisher. Closer examination reveals greatest hits of the more intimate kind: a love letter from a wartime girlfriend, a photo of him on a cruise in 1977 wearing an absurd hat with one arm flung over the shoulder of a comely older woman (not Junior’s mother, he’s not surprised to see), and a black-and-white photo of Smith in 1945 leaning in close to use a young woman’s collarbone to sign an autograph.
“Dad,” his son says drily, “had the reputation of being well endowed.”
Some members of Maynard Smith Sr.’s immediate family, including a son and daughter from previous marriages, stopped speaking to him. One of his three sons died of an overdose before his father passed, the other became lost in drug abuse and died just five years after his father. Maynard Sr.’s other daughter enjoyed her paternal relationship, but she and her mother had the stronger bond and lived together in Hawaii and Florida after the couple divorced. But Maynard Smith and his namesake stayed close until the end.
In late April 1984, the elder Maynard Smith staggered into the kitchen, gasping words but garbling them badly. “Oak, oak, oak,” he finally managed. Treated for a stroke, doctors discovered his heart was also failing. After a grueling month in the hospital, he was gone.
“He was not the type of man who would listen to doctors,” says Debby Wolfsmith, Maynard Smith Jr.’s wife. “He wasn’t going to stop putting salt on his watermelon. He wasn’t good at keeping up with medications, either.”
Looking over the contents of the three steamer trunks, it’s clear that Maynard Smith Sr. curated this collection of memorabilia, intentionally or not, to be the idealized version of his life. The news clippings paint the portrait of a dedicated son, a war hero, and a successful publisher with the ear of important people.
The positive media coverage is extensive, but Smith left the negative press out of his personal archives. There are articles describing lawsuits against him, tangles with the Food and Drug Administration over a male enhancement cream, and an arrest for filing a false police report for his role in a very public hoax in 1952. There are a variety of columnists, local and national, taking potshots at his character.
The most famous detractor is Andy Rooney, who calls Smith Sr. “a fuck up” in his World War II memoirs, My War. The television columnist, with Stars and Stripes during World War II, is the most responsible for both creating and denigrating Smith’s public image. The two short, opinionated men enjoyed bucking authority—maybe they had too much in common to get along.
Others offer mixed reactions to his name, even thirty-five years after his death. A public affairs employee at the Medal of Honor Society remembers Smith as “a crackpot” and “someone who wasn’t shy about putting people in their place.” Caroline Sheen, the veteran photo and art editor of Air & Space Smithsonian magazine, immediately dubs him “the most despised man to get the Medal of Honor.” His brother-in-law, George Rayner, recalls him as “a wheeler dealer” and adds, not unkindly, that “he was crazy.” His daughter Christine speaks of his keen intelligence but notes of his love life that “he didn’t leave many unbroken hearts behind him.”
Maynard Smith Jr. sums it up by saying, “He was a rebel, I guess you’d say.”
Maynard Smith’s personality produced lots of nicknames. The one that endures is “Snuffy Smith,” after a short, irascible cartoon character. In a strange sort of immortality, this moniker is enshrined in the modern Air Force lexicon. It’s not used as often these days but the 2019 online Urban Dictionary includes this entry:
AIRMAN SNUFFY: Hypothetical alias of an enlisted person in the U.S. Air Force who can’t seem to do anything right. Used frequently in Air Force officer training texts and case studies, Airman Snuffy is analogous to the U.S. Marine Corps’ Gomer Pyle.
War dehumanizes people, and not always in the expected ways. In World War II, the U.S. military and news media partnered to manufacture heroes that could be used and discarded like any other piece of general issue equipment. Smith’s unlikely experience is a prime example of this public relations machine in action, and its unintended consequences. Smith encountered harrowing violence, the expected root of wartime psychological trauma, but he also suffered the stranger fate of being reduced to a public caricature.
So this is not a book about the War Department’s hero, “Snuffy Smith.” This is a book about Maynard Harrison Smith Sr. and his wild ride through cataclysmic history.
To understand the man in any kind of context requires opening the aperture to capture more than just his role in the European air war, although that proves to be the defining event of his life. His background is necessary to understand his reaction to war, just as the trajectory of his postwar path measures just how deeply the war impacted his life.
Surrounding Smith’s narrative are those in the 8th Air Force who fought the savage and often senseless air campaign over Europe. Comparing his wartime experience to theirs (particularly Smith’s friend, Marcel St. Louis) is mandatory when trying to find Smith’s rightful place in history. There is also something to be said for comparing Smith’s often selfish behavior against the negligent and murderous decisions of the 8th Air Force in 1942 and 1943. His sins pale when next to some of the poor command choices that unnecessarily killed tens of thousands of Allied airmen.
This tale can only be appreciated when a reader can abandon the kind of intonations found in Tom Brokaw’s 1998 book The Greatest Generation. In it, he describes World War II veterans as “mature beyond their years, tempered by what they had been through, disciplined by their military training and sacrifices.… They stayed true to their values of personal responsibility, duty, honor, and faith.”
Copyright © 2020 by Joe Pappalardo