Chapter 1
“When I said I wanted sand between my toes, this wasn’t exactly what I meant.” I stared down in dismay at the cat litter that was supposed to be in the litter box, but somehow had managed to cover half the floor of my cat café instead.
Adele Barrows, my star volunteer and fellow crazy cat lady—dare I say maybe even a little crazier than me—handed me a dustpan without even looking up from where she was scooping cat food into bowls with her other hand. “They’re cats. Whaddaya expect?” she said with her pack-a-day rasp. I’d been trying to convince Adele to quit smoking for a year now, to no avail.
I took the dustpan, biting back my retort, not wanting to sound like a complainer. After all, Adele normally did most of the cleaning here at JJ’s House of Purrs, Daybreak Island’s first and only cat café and me and my partner Ethan Birdsong’s brainchild. We’d soft-launched a year ago when I’d moved back to the island on a whim after a decade-long absence, turning my Grandpa Leo’s huge home into part cat shelter, part expanded residence and giving Grandpa a starring role as co-owner. JJ’s was named after Junkyard Johnny, the stray cat I’d adopted upon my return. He’d found me at my grandmother’s funeral and we immediately became besties. He’d also been the inspiration for the café. And while we’d seen much success in our first—and mostly rushed—iteration, this new summer season was going to be epic, in my opinion.
Last year we’d opened with our dining room as the cat café and Grandpa’s kitchen as our coffee and baking base. It had worked, but wasn’t ideal for, you know, living in the actual house. This year we were in a much better place. We’d done extensive renovations, which were now complete, the food operations had moved to the garage-turned-food-service-area—Ethan’s dream since we’d moved here—and my accompanying store with JJ merchandise was fully stocked. I’d also opened an online store that was getting a lot of traction. JJ was a superstar on the island and his reputation had already spread far and wide thanks to the great publicity we’d gotten since our opening. What better way to keep promoting that than putting his adorable face on sweatpants, coffee mugs, tote bags, and other souvenirs?
“I know,” I said now, in response to Adele’s comment. “But it was easier to manage with ten cats. Which was my limit, if you recall. Then I let Katrina guilt me into another five. Pretty soon we’ll all have to move out to make room for the cats.” I motioned to the more-crowded-by-the-second café area, where a family of kittens currently wrestled, tumbling over one another in that flexible kitten way they had. I’d had to add two cat trees just the other day, and even though we’d just expanded the café space, I felt like it was already too small again.
They were stinking cute, though.
When I’d opened the café in response to a need on the island after the only other rescue center had closed due to lack of funding, I’d been firm in my limit. It was Grandpa Leo’s house, after all, and he and I, along with Ethan, JJ, and my sister Val, had to live here too. And for the last few months my boyfriend Lucas and his dog Oliver had pretty much moved in, so we were kind of a full house. But Katrina Denning, my good friend and the town’s animal control officer, had worn me down. She knew I could never say no to a furry face in trouble and she took full advantage of that. Now we were up to fifteen. And the latest residents were the messiest. Adorable, but messy. A mom and her litter of six kittens. No foster homes had been available, so they showed up at our door.
“Budget cuts,” Adele said with a shrug. “You know how it is. Katrina’s in a rough spot.”
“I know, I know,” I sighed. The police department as a whole was facing budget cuts at the start of the fiscal year, which meant the animal control budget would take the hardest hit. It just wasn’t that important to some police chiefs. When Grandpa Leo had been chief he had been different, but his replacement wasn’t of the same mind.
“Anyway, I wouldn’t care, but today of all days I want the place to look good.” I sank to my knees and began dutifully sweeping as Tommy, our orange and white triple-pawed kitty, watched with interest, hanging over the side of the tree with his face on his paws.
“That’s right, your fancy-pants rescue lady is coming.” Adele made a face.
“What fancy-pants rescue lady?” Mish Warner, one of my newer volunteers and a childhood friend, walked into the room with a stack of freshly washed litter boxes. Mish had started volunteering with me a month or so ago. She said she needed something fulfilling to do when she wasn’t running her pet supply store, A Pawsitive Experience. She and her husband Stevie both loved cats and were looking to adopt a feline friend for their Yorkie, Pebbles. Mish, Stevie, and I had all gone to school together since kindergarten. But unlike me, neither of them had ever left the island. They’d been high school sweethearts and gotten married in their early twenties. And as far as I knew, they still liked each other. It was cute.
“That woman from the rescue league that doesn’t really rescue anything,” Adele said with a disdainful sniff.
“What woman from the rescue league?” Mish asked, looking at me.
“Adele! That’s not nice.” I wagged a finger at her.
“It’s true!” Adele protested. “They have no shelter. They like to run fancy parties and get their names in the paper, is all.”
“They use their funding for spay/neuter clinics, foster home networks, and lobbying for animal rights.” I frowned at her then turned to Mish. “She’s not that fancy. She just happens to run a well-known rescue league. One that does a lot of good work raising money,” I added with a side-eye to Adele.
Adele snorted. She wasn’t one to suffer fools easily—or anyone she deemed rich and pretentious. I wasn’t sure my impending guest fit either of those categories, but once Adele had something in her mind, there was no getting it out.
“Really,” Mish said in an odd voice. “Which one?”
“Shoreline Animal Rescue League in New Jersey,” I said. I had to admit, I was a tiny bit starstruck by this request. I’d been following the League since I was a kid. Granted they weren’t our neighbors—we were out here on a little island off the coast of Massachusetts—but they had a presence that seeped all the way into the northeast corner of the country, well beyond the tri-state area. They always had compelling marketing materials and excellent tug-the-heartstrings stories about animals they’d helped save and policies they’d helped implement, both federal and statewide. Their fundraisers were legendary and attracted all kinds of celebrity endorsers, and they had extensive reach and influence around the entire East Coast when it came to effecting change for animals.
So when Jillian Allen, the executive director, called me out of the blue and asked to meet with me, I immediately said yes. She said she was coming to the island on business and wanted to see this “famous” up-and-coming cat café for herself—and meet JJ, of course. Which had won me over, but hadn’t sat well with Adele.
“On business?” she’d snorted. “Like what? Scoping out her new summer house?”
I had no idea, and I honestly didn’t care. I was flattered that they’d taken notice of us and our café and certainly wasn’t going to look for an ulterior motive. I also figured maybe they wanted to start a foster network out here or something.
“What’s her name?” Mish asked in kind of a strangled voice.
I took a closer look at her. She looked funny all of a sudden. Her lips were twisted in a weird shape and she stood frozen as a statue, still clutching the litter boxes. “Jillian Allen. You okay?”
“Hmm? Oh, yes of course. Just kind of hungry.” She smiled, but it seemed forced.
I could sympathize. When I was hungry I turned into a beast. “Why don’t you go grab something from Ethan? You know he’s always cooking or baking some kind of deliciousness.” Now that our café was open, Ethan spent most of his time out in the newly converted garage making all kinds of treats. Including vegan and gluten-free options.
“Good idea,” Mish said. She dropped the stack of litter boxes where she stood with more force than I thought necessary, sending the more skittish cats scrambling for cover, and headed out the door.
Adele shook her head and bent to pick up the boxes. “So how does this woman know about you anyway? No offense,” she added. “It’s just that New Jersey isn’t right down the street.”
“She heard about us through some research into new East Coast rescues,” I said. “Said they want to start helping smaller places throughout the region. We’ll find out more today.”
Adele was clearly still skeptical. “They should help more places. And stop paying people fancy-pants salaries when they could use that money to save more animals. I have no respect for places that don’t get their hands dirty, Maddie. You know that about me.”
“I do know that about you. And I get it,” I said. “But different places run differently and it doesn’t mean they care any less about the animals. They just have their own way of getting things done.”
“Yeah, without doing the hard work,” Adele shot back. “Anyway, what time is she coming?”
I glanced at my watch. “Around three, she said. I have to make sure this place is in tip-top shape.” I winked at her to let her know I was kidding. With Adele, it was always in tip-top shape. While I wished she was better at taking care of her own health and well-being—i.e., quitting smoking and cutting back on the boxes of wine—when it came to the cats, she was a complete perfectionist. “Grandpa is looking forward to doing his thing and showing the place off. You can stick around and help too if you want. That’s part of the shelter-manager role, after all.”
Just last week I had offered Adele a real, paying job as our full-time café manager, and I was over the moon about it. Although she was probably going to keep at least one of her three other jobs, this might help take some of the load off her. It would definitely take some off of me.
“’Course I’ll stick around. I wanna see just how full of crap she is.” Adele grinned at me. “Now. Why don’t you go get some coffee and I’ll finish here. You do a lousy job with a dustpan anyway.”
Chapter 2
Half an hour later I was showered, freshly caffeinated, and ready to show off the café to the fullest. I’d traded my litter-cleaning sweats for a cute new summery dress I’d ordered online last week and felt much more presentable. I picked up my phone to text Lucas before I went into the café. My boyfriend—I still loved saying that—had a full day of grooming appointments today at the salon he owned, Diva Dogs and Classy Cats, and he’d taken Oliver to work with him knowing we’d have a full house. His place was the only full-service, year-round grooming business on the island, and it came in handy for me with all the cats who needed freshening up after their rescues. Of course, I’d been able to negotiate a good rate given that I knew the owner and all.
Getting ready for the big visit, I texted. Wish you and Ollie were here.
Figuring his hands were deep in a sink full of dog hair and it would be a while before I heard back, I stuck my phone back in my pocket and whistled for JJ, who immediately came running. The two of us headed toward the café. On the way, I glanced out the back window and caught sight of Mish, outside on the phone, holding a cup of coffee. I paused to watch her walk around talking, waving her cup around. At one point the coffee splashed out onto her shirt and it didn’t look like she even noticed. Her jerky, stiff movements told me she was agitated. I wondered if she was having a fight with Stevie. I hoped not.
I pulled open the French doors separating the main house from the café and let JJ in ahead of me. He bolted right for the kittens, squeaking non-stop. He loved the little ones.
The cats’ portion of the house was an expanded version of our former dining room. We’d taken down walls, added on a few hundred square feet, and opened up this whole west side of the house into an expansive cat haven. We’d added multiple built-in shelves for them to climb, beams coming off the ceiling where they could walk over everyone’s heads, hidey-holes—everything and anything to create a veritable feline playground. They had beds and toys galore, of course, and we’d built a cabinet along one wall to hide the row of litter boxes. It served a dual purpose—we had beds on top so they could hang out. Then of course we’d added seating for the visitors, both seats as well as beanbag chairs, floor pillows, and—my personal favorite—a couple of those cool Moon Pod chairs. Each wall was a different color—hot pink, orange, green, or blue—and we had colorful pillows scattered around the room.
I loved the atmosphere we’d created. It was super fun and comfortable. And today, crowded. Adele was cleaning. Again. Someone must have kicked more litter around—probably the kittens. Adele was funny. For all her skepticism about our visitor today, she wouldn’t stand for the café to look less than perfect, no matter who was coming. One of our volunteers, Harry, a retired widower who I thought was sweet on Adele, was also there. He held a feather toy high in the air, coaxing Murray, one of the more playful cats, to jump for it. Although I noticed him sneaking adoring gazes at Adele whenever she wasn’t paying attention. Which she usually wasn’t, as long as there were cats around.
Ethan and Val were in the corner trying to coax one of the more shy residents, George, out from under one of the cabinets. The more curious cats were out and on alert. They even looked anticipatory, many of them watching the activity around them intently. There wasn’t usually this much activity all at once. We spaced out visitors so as not to stress the cats out and to make sure they were showing up at their best for our guests, and we usually only had a few people working in the café at once depending on the amount of appointments we had.
Grandpa sat on one of the couches, looking comfortable and relaxed in one of his cat café outfits. Every time he worked the café or did any publicity for it, he had a special wardrobe. Sometimes it was silly and fun, like his cats-in-yoga-poses button-down shirt. Other times it was more serious. Today he’d gone the more serious route, with jeans and an Arm the Animals T-shirt—the classic design, featuring a cat with a hand grenade. He wore a JJ’s House of Purrs hat over his bushy white hair. Seventy-five years young and he had more hair than most guys I knew in their thirties. I loved that he was a walking advertisement for the café. He hardly ever set foot outside without some branded gear, even when he was in private investigator mode.
“So do you have a spiel ready for our guest?” Grandpa asked Adele.
Adele shot him a look over her shoulder, but couldn’t keep the smile off her face. “Yeah. It’ll be all about how we do actual rescue work here and not just dress up in fancy clothes and have parties.”
“Adele. You better not,” I warned.
“Is that really all they do?” Val asked, absentmindedly rubbing Ethan’s arm. He responded by taking her hand and squeezing it tight. They were still in the cutesy, in-love stage of their relationship. They’d gotten together after Val and her loser husband Cole Tanner had split up last year shortly after I’d returned home. Val had moved back to Grandpa’s, and we’d all ended up living together like one big happy family. Or hippie commune. Some days I wasn’t sure which it was.
Copyright © 2021 by Liz Mugavero.
